Wednesday, September 12, 2018

More on Vosges

    Here are three more pictures of the Vosges Mountains and fortifications there that Kevin Adams took.  The first, a panorama, confirms what Kevin said about how rugged the mountains are although they aren't particularly high.  The second shows a well-reinforced trench above a steep slope, making it almost impossible to attack.  The third is of a sign, in three languages, explaining how strong the German fortifications were.  Little wonder this was considered a quiet sector: the German defenses were too strong to attack.  Dad told me that when they moved into the French trenches in this area, they had been occupied so long that rats had taken up residence.  According to Dad, one American soldier was killed one night when his comrade fired at a rat but hit his fellow soldier instead.  From then on, Dad said, they were ordered not to shoot at rats.  In the last photo, notice how close the opposing lines were.



3 comments:

  1. Were those walls built during the war?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Here is what Kevin says: "I had the same question myself. There was a placard that mentioned the Germans having to tunnel through some tough rock in that area, so I think they used the debris to line the trenches, though I didn't see any signs that specifically said that. The French trenches were just a few meters away, just down the slope from the German lines, and they're still visible, though just as lines of mounds and depressions in the ferns. Given that it's been French territory for most of the time since WWI, I don't think they would've lined the German side and not the French, so I think the stone-lined trenches were original. (The preservation due to the stone walls is probably why the historic site is there. This wasn't the site of any turning-point battle.)"

    ReplyDelete
  3. And here is what Meredith says: "Yes, I think they were original. One of the signs said the German army brought in miners from Germany to build the trenches. Several signs repeated how well-fortified the German lines were compared the impromptu French lines, which were just dug into the hill side. Another sign said 17,000 men died there, and I think it was during a period of just a few months in 1915."

    ReplyDelete